8 Best AI Music Generators Compared

It was only logical for Elevenlabs to make its own AI music generator as they are the experts for AI generated voices and music is only a stone throw and huge target audience away.
They have just recently launched this application and I'm positively surprised by the quality of it.
Song and lyrics quality are both 3 out of 5, I'd say, nothing amazing but also not silly.
Eleven Music will create a timeline divided by song parts such as Verse 1, Pre-Chorus, Bridge etc. which is super handy and allows changing only certain parts.
But my free 10.000 credits are used up pretty quickly (one song generation cost me about 3000 credits) and I can't download the generated music without signing up.
Also if you don't change it, it will automatically create 2 variations of the song at once.

Soundraw is more of a beatmaker for musicians than a tool that creates the end music product. Here we have to choose the genre from a catalog instead of prompting it. You can add various genres to merge into one song, and a producer dashboard below the track allows you to make changes to each section of the song. Since I couldn't prompt the Beyonce song, I gave it quite a challenge with mixing House with Dancehall, which it really didn't do well. Another genre mix with R&B and Tropical House did much better. I think this is a good tool for people starting out with music production who want to take their first steps on a small budget. Real musicians will outgrow it before even starting.

Bandlab is like a midjourney for music producers, simply because it seems very community based. You set up a profile and can contact other musicians through the platform for collaborations. The AI music generator is actually an idea generator or let's say a starting point. Its approach is completely different to the other tools and much more professional. You can e.g. adjust the beats per minute (bpm) and you can modify the key. Pretty cool, although more for advanced musicians. Also, I gave fewer points for onboarding because you have to go through a series of questions before getting started (which probably make a lot of sense for professionals).

AI Music Generator is a positive surprise. Judging by the simple interface, I thought the music generation would be rather clunky too. But no, the songs generated with this tool are definitely among my favorites. I should have added more lyrics, because this tool doesn't add more to the chorus unless you let AI completely generate them. Elevenlab for example just filled in the rest. So overall, not too much choice here, choose male or female voice, add lyrics, keywords for style, but great results!

I remember when I was a kid I would often sing along English songs, but since I didn't speak the language yet I made gibberish lyrics up. And that is also kind of how Udio sounds. Which is a pity, because otherwise it's a great tool! Where others had glitches (Suno) or simply created terrible music (Beathoven), Udio delivered. And I have to say, not all vocals sounded completely silly. What also confused me is that even though I had prompted a female vocalist (Udio automatically turns Beyonce into various keywords describing her), it generated half of the songs with a male vocalist. Still, I will keep an eye on Udio, I think they will improve a lot in the next few months.

Suno is probably the most famous AI music generator, at least the one I have heard most of. Let's you download every song layer separately and similar to Midjourneys character consistency, you can create a voice persona and use it throughout various tracks (on the pro version). User experience is not as smooth as with Eleven Music, for example I wanted to copy my prompt in but it was too long. Instead of just indicating why it wouldn't copy, nothing happened. There are a few glitches like that. What bums me the most is that I've created a super nice version but I only received 3 seconds of it, then it had a bug and they refunded the credits. I tried 4 times, every time it was the same. And according to perplexity this happens a lot with Suno, so I have to deduct quite a few points, even though I really liked the beginning of the song and would have loved to listen to the full thing.

Mubert, I'm not sure what to do with you. On one side I love your fresh approach, for example you can upload an image instead of using a prompt to generate a picture (image-to-music). Also I love that you would let me generate a jingle for free, when I was looking for this for my podcast KI Plausch, I couldn't find this feature anywhere and just cut out a piece of an ai-generated song. I haven't seen this anywhere else. But then your core product doesn't convince me: the AI-generated music track. The Beyonce song was complete crap as you can see in the video above. And let's not even speak about the Image-to-Music track...

On Beathoven's homepage they say that they create background music for your projects, so it looks like the R'n'B song I prompted will be a challenge for the tool. And indeed, not just that, but in general generating a song that is a pleasant experience to listen to is a challenge in itself. Check out the video above to see what I mean, its creation is simply terrible.